Category Archives: Chinese Head Tax issues + Gim Wong's Ride for Redress

Head Tax Apology viewing today! at Hotel Vancouver in Vancouver

Hello friends and head tax descendants


It’s a historic day in Canada today, as Prime Minister Stephen Harper apologizes for the racist head tax.

Many of our ancestors would have paid the head tax, levied only against ethnic Chinese when they immigrated to Canada between 1885 to 1923.  In 1923, The Chinese Exclusion Act lasted until 1947.

Tomorrow the Government of Canada will apologize for the racist head tax.

The BC Coalition of Head Tax Payers, Spouses and Descendants is asking for One Certificate, One payment.  This is fair as many sons and daughters, as well as grandchildren all suffered the  economic, cultural and social challenges created by both head tax and Chinese Exclusion Act from 1885 to 1947, and beyond.

If you are in Vancouver, please join me and other family members and friends at: Fairmont Hotel Vancouver at 12:00 noon (PDT)
Burrard & Georgia St.

My great-great-grandfather Rev. Chan Yu Tan arrived in Canada in 1896, but was possibly exempt as a missionary.  This exemption would not have applied for his children, nor the many family members that came later, nor the people that our ancestors married, such as my great-grandmother Kate (Chan) Lee’s husband Ernest Lee. My father’s father Wong Wah arrived in 1886
and would have also had to pay for my grandmother Wong Chan Sze.

 

Chinese Head Tax information and stories.  Where to go?  What to find? How to register head tax certificates.

People can go to the websites listed below for head tax registration with community groups.  This information will be presented to the Government to help identify head tax certificate information.  It is NOT official government registration.

image
BC Coaltion for Head Tax Payers, Spouses and Descendants.
www.headtaxpayers.ca

imageimage
Chinese Canadian National Council
http://www.ccnc.ca/sectionEntry.php?entryID=72&type=Event

Ontario Coalition for Head Tax Payers and Families
www.headtaxredress.org

image

Vancouver Public Library is now inundated with patrons seeking head tax information.  Click on http://www.vpl.ca/ccg/
Head Tax Information – info sheets are available in CHINESE and
ENGLISH

imageimageimage
For stories on head tax issues collected and/or written by Todd Wong:
http://www.gunghaggisfatchoy.com/blog/ChineseHeadTaxissuesGimWongsRideforRedress

image
Chinese Canadian Historical Society of BC
www.cchsbc.ca

 

Head Tax redress package…. a leak… what will Harper say?


Head Tax redress package…. a leak… what will Harper say?


Today on Global TV news, the reporter said that Head Tax payers and spouses would be recieving $20,000.  But is she just anticipating what the Head Tax Redress groups such as CCNC, Ontario Coalition and BC Coalition have been asking for?

Earlier today, Head Tax redress groups recieved information at that:

Harper will apologize tomorrow ; (pls read Don Martin's coments in today national post); announces a 10-15 million dollar community fund, to be managed by the govt; no community compensation; no compensation for first generation; only surviving payers and
spouses will receive one-time compensation of between 15k to
10k.


If this is true, then there will be many dispointed people.  Everybody is expecting an apology, but the “compensation” is substantially less than the $35,000 that head tax payer Charlie Quon would like, and less than the $20,000 that head tax redress groups see as a minimum.  BC Coalition has been stating “One certificate – one payment.”

But hopefully, this is part of the 2 stage process that the Head Tax redress groups have been proposing all along.  Stage one includes apology + immediate redress payment for surviving head tax payers + spouses.  Stage two includes payments for descendants, to be negotiated over an 8 to 12 month process, acknowledging it will take time to register head tax certificates and prove direct lineage of descendants.

One certificate – one payment.  I believe this is fair.  It is like a tax refund.  A symbolic tax refund, for the exremely racist legislation that was created to keep Chinese out of Canada, while letting any other race in.  Very poor judgement on Canada's part, especially after seeking, inviting, recruiting, and hiring Chinese labourers to build the Canadian transcontinental railway at substantially lower wages than White labourers.

There are many head tax payers and spouses who have now died and gone to heaven.  Some were buried with their certificates.  Their children suffered the financial setbacks along with their parents.  Their grandchildren too.  My maternal great grand father Ernest Lee, and my maternal grandfather Sonny Mar both worked hard to pay the head tax, and they both died early leaving their widowed wives with children to look after.

Canada need to make the apology so that our country can move forward.  To the many Canadians who say “no compensation – get over it” – I say that financial redress is important and part of the process.  Accept it, share in the celebration, and get over it.  The United Nations asked Canada in 2004 to make an apology and financial redress, following New Zealand's example.

If we do not make an apology and proper redress, then future generations of multi-racial Canadians, will all be head tax descendants of a Canada that did not want their ancestors, refused to make apology for deliberately racist legislation, and refused to make fair and honourable redress when head tax payers, spouses and descendants were still alive.  This would be the legacy and the burden that we would leave to our grandchildren and their grandchildren.  Or we can make a proper fair and honourable redress and move on to the healing of our country.




CCNC Delegates Ride Redress Train – Redress in Ottawa – simulcast ceremonies in Toronto and Vancouver

CDM dividing line

For background information about the head tax, visit
www.headtaxredress.org.

http://www.canadiandemocraticmovement.ca/displayarticle881.html

 

Subject: (Redress) CCNC Delegates Ride Redress Train

 For Immediate Release 

June 21, 2006

 

CCNC Delegates Ride
Redress Train

 Toronto/Vancouver – On Thursday, June 22nd, 2006, the
Government of Canada will issue a formal apology to the head tax families and
Chinese Canadian community for the injustices of the Head Tax and Chinese
Exclusion Act.

Members of the Chinese Canadian National Council (CCNC) delegation led
by Colleen Hua, CCNC National President, will be joining the Redress Train as
it departs Toronto
this morning:

 
Depart from Toronto (VIA Rail Train 42) on Wednesday,
June 21, at 9:30 a.m. EDT. Delegation to meet in Toronto Union Station at VIA
Rail’s Blue & Silver Lounge at 8:00 am EDT;

Arrive in Ottawa Wednesday, June 21, at main VIA train
station (Tremblay Road)
at 2:04 pm EDT.


The CCNC delegation in Ottawa
includes Dr. Joseph Wong, Victor Wong, George Lau and Gary Yee. There will be
simultaneous satellite broadcast of the Ottawa
proceedings in Toronto and Vancouver on Thursday.

 
    Toronto:
Westin Harbour Castle
at 3:00 pm (EDT)

CCNC Spokesperson:
Cynthia Pay

 

Vancouver:
Fairmont Hotel Vancouver
at 12:00 noon (PDT)

CCNC Spokesperson: Sid
Tan

CCNC – Ottawa will host a banquet
after the events on Parliament Hill at the Chu Shing Restaurant at 691 Somerset Street West
in Ottawa on
Thursday, June 22
(6 pm). The contact person is Ms. Willy Lee at (613) 738-8888.

CCNC is a national human rights organization with 27 chapters across Canada.
CCNC and other redress-seeking groups across Canada have pressed successive
Federal Governments since 1984 to provide redress for the Chinese Head Tax 1885
-1923, Newfoundland Head Tax 1906 – 1949 and the Chinese Exclusion Act 1923 –
1947.

-30-

 

For more
information, please contact:

Colleen Hua (647)
299-1775

Dr. Joseph Wong,
(416) 806-0082

Sid Tan, (604) 783-1853

Victor Wong, (416)
977-9871 or (647) 285-2262

Cynthia Pay, (416) 531-2411 ext 228

 

NDP CALLS ON GOVERNMENT TO PROVIDE FAIR DEAL FOR CHINESE HEAD TAX PAYERS

FOR
IMMEDIATE RELEASE
NOVEMBER
22, 2005

NDP
CALLS ON GOVERNMENT TO PROVIDE FAIR DEAL FOR CHINESE HEAD TAX PAYERS

OTTAWA NDP Leader Jack Layton
along with his caucus colleagues, House Leader Libby Davies (Vancouver East),
Immigration Critic Bill Siksay (Burnaby-Douglas) and
MP Peter Julian (Burnaby-New-Westminster), urged the Prime Minister to find a
compromise and fair deal for all Chinese Canadian head tax payers and their
families, today.

“These
families deserve an apology and real respect from this government,” said Layton. In a letter to
the Prime Minister, the Federal NDP questioned the government’s reasoning
in allocating $12.5 million for a redress project to a single organization
without including thousands of head tax payers, their families and their
representatives.

“It
is completely inadequate for this government to exclude at least 4000 head tax
payers, their families and descendants through a lump sum agreement with only
one organization,“ said Davies.

$12.5
million has been allocated to Chinese Canadians through the Acknowledgement,
Commemoration and Education (ACE) Fund, established for communities affected by
wartime and similar past measures. The government is expected to announce
Wednesday that it will sign over the entire allocation to the National Congress
of Chinese Canadians, despite calls from several other organizations, such as
the Chinese Canadian National Council, to be involved in any commemorative,
educational or other key measures that may arise from the fund. 

“At
the forefront of the redress movement is the Chinese Canadian National Council,
which represents thousands of head tax payers and their families,” said Layton, “but if
this deal goes forward in its current form, CCNC will have no say in how the
funds will be spent.”

“The
Prime Minister should remember his responsibility to find a course of
compromise that will address the needs of the diverse community of Chinese
Canadians that deserve to be acknowledged here,” said Julian.

“Finding
a compromise to address the injustices committed against Chinese immigrants to Canada over a
period of decades should be this government’s first priority,”
added Siksay

The
Canadian government collected $23 million from Chinese Immigrants to Canada between
1885 and 1923.

-30-

For
more information, please contact:
Jack Layton
Karl Belanger: (613) 995-6767
Libby
Davies
Leanne Holt: (613) 992-6036
Bill Siksay
  Sonja vanDieen:
(613) 996-5599
Peter Julian
Henri Sader: (613) 992-4215

Question posed by
Libby Davies today in the House of Commons:

“Last Sunday was Father's Day, but many Chiense Canadians never knew their fathers because of the racist head tax..  Very few of them could celebrate because their fathers died waiting for an apology and redress.

Half an hour ago, hundreds of frail seniors arrived on a train to Ottawa with hope for justice at last.  But justice must also include redress for families, without it, there is no reconciliation.

Will the Prime Minister do the right thing tomorrow and offer compensation to Head tax descendants?”

 

CCNC June 22 message for Head Tax redress

Chinese
Canadian National Council – Chinese Head Tax and Exclusion Act Redress

It’s been a long journey, but well worth the time, effort and
hard work to seek resolution, closure, and justice for the Chinese Canadian
community.

When CCNC first started organizing community meetings on the issue of
redress for the Chinese Head Tax and Exclusion Act in the mid 1980’s,
none of the original organizers ever thought that in the year 2006, more than
20 years later, that this issue would still remained unresolved. At that time,
more than 2,600 Head Tax payers and their families, registered with us to let
the Government see that real people felt the effects of racist legislation. In
the early 1990s, the B.C. Coalition of Head Tax Payers, Spouses and Descendants
helped to register another 1,500 new claimants who also authorized CCNC to
advocate on their behalf. Today, only a handful of Head Tax payers or their
surviving spouses remain alive.

However, the year 2006 promises to be a year that will become an
historical landmark for the Chinese Canadian community. Over the last year,
CCNC in collaboration with other redress-seeking groups who are primarily Head
Tax payers and their families, have made significant inroads to bringing about
resolution of the redress issue. The Prime Minister has taken action to fulfill
his promise to apologize and provide appropriate redress to the Head Tax payers
and their families.

This is a historic day for the Chinese Canadian community.  Our hardships and our contributions have
been recognized.  Our Government has
finally taken responsibility for resolving this long-standing issue of
justice.  While it is truly
regrettable that most of our elderly pioneers have passed away without hearing
this official apology, we are grateful for the urgency with which the Prime
Minister has moved on this issue for the benefit of the remaining Head Tax
payers and spouses.

At this moment, the Government recognizes the history of our
community’s pioneers’ contributions to this nation.  As
the process of
genuine reconciliation begins, we remain committed to a just and honourable
resolution so that our community may finally move forward as full and equal
members of Canadian society.    

Colleen Hua                                         

National President                                

June 22, 2006

 

 

REDRESS TRAIN arrives in Ottawa

image

For Immediate Release 

June 21, 2006
 

Redress Train Arrives in Ottawa

 
Toronto/Vancouver/Ottawa – Chinese Canadians aboard the Redress
Train have now arrived in Ottawa
to witness the Government of Canada issue a formal apology on Thursday to the head
tax families and Chinese Canadian community for the injustices of the Head Tax
and Chinese Exclusion Act.

The Chinese Canadian National Council (CCNC) delegation is led by
Colleen Hua, CCNC National President and includes Dr. Joseph Wong, Founding
CCNC President; Victor Wong, CCNC Executive Director and former Chair of the BC
Coalition of Head Tax Payers, Spouses and Descendants; George Lau, Co-Chair of
the Ontario Coalition of Chinese Head Tax Payers and Families and Gary Yee,
former CCNC National President.

CCNC has designated spokespersons at venues in Toronto
and Vancouver where families can congregate for
the simultaneous broadcast of the Ottawa
proceedings on Thursday:

Toronto:
Westin Harbour Castle at 3:00 pm (EDT)

CCNC Spokesperson: Cynthia
Pay

Vancouver:
Fairmont Hotel Vancouver
at 12:00 noon (PDT)

CCNC Spokesperson: Sid
Tan

CCNC has learned that the Government will arrange for an outdoor tent
and TV hookup outside of the Parliament Buildings tomorrow as well for those
who are unable to find a seat inside.

CCNC – Ottawa will host a banquet
after the events on Parliament Hill at the Chu Shing
Restaurant at 691 Somerset
Street West in Ottawa on Thursday evening at 6pm. The contact
person is Ms. Willy Lee at (613) 738-8888.

CCNC is a national human rights organization with 27 chapters across Canada.
CCNC and other redress-seeking groups across Canada have pressed successive
Federal Governments since 1984 to provide redress for the Chinese Head Tax 1885
-1923, Newfoundland Head Tax 1906 – 1949 and the Chinese Exclusion Act 1923 –
1947.

-30-

 

For more
information please contact:

Colleen Hua (647)
299-1775

Dr. Joseph Wong,
(416) 806-0082

Sid Tan, (604)
783-1853

Victor Wong, (416)
977-9871 or (647) 285-2262

Cynthia Pay, (416) 531-2411 ext 228

 

Vancouver Sun: Redress Train rolls by ghosts of the past

imageimage
Vancouver Sun: Redress Train rolls by ghosts of the past

Vancouver Sun writer Ian Mulgrew is on board the Redress Train from Vancouver to Ottawa.  He is accompanying head tax descendants on their journey to witness PM Stephen Harper give an apology for the Chinese head tax in parliament.  83 year old WW2 veteran, Gim Wong, son of a head tax payer is on the train with his wife Jan.  Toronto lawyer and activist Susan Eng, head tax descendant is on the train with her mother.  I saw them off in Vancouver on Friday.

Publication: Vancouver Sun;
Date:2006 Jun 19; Section:Front Page; Page Number:
A3

image

COLUMNIST

 

Redress
train rolls by ghosts of the past

 

IAN
MULGREW

VANCOUVER SUN

 


   ABOARD THE HEAD TAX REDRESS TRAIN A s the transcontinental
train clattered eastward through the Rockies, Toronto's Susan Eng entertained
tourists with stories of the 22-year struggle by Chinese Canadians for
redress over the long-gone discriminatory head tax.
   More time, Eng told them, would have allowed the groups
involved to better organize the response to P rime Minister Stephen Harper's
surprise announcement last week that he would apologize for the unique
penalty imposed on the Chinese more than a century ago.
   “It would have been nice along the way on this trip
to commemorate the thousands of Chinese workers who gave their lives to build
the railway,” Eng said.
   But the train rumbled through Kamloops at
midnight and most of the sites appropriate for a ritualistic nod to the
ghosts of the past were also shrouded in darkness as the train sped by.
   Later, the observation car filled with “ahs” at
the appearance of Thunder Falls on the opposite side of mirror-like Moose Lake near the B.C.-Alberta border.
   “Wow,” Eng echoed, watching the spectacular
spires and rugged ranges through which her ancestors helped carve and blast a
steel path.
   She said she hopes this thrown-together trip will
nevertheless focus Canadians' attention and help them understand why the
prime minister’s decision means so much to the minority community.
   James Marr, 94, and his family had only two days notice
before they boarded the Canadian in Edmonton late Saturday for the trip to
Ottawa.
   “He's quite overwhelmed,” daughter Lily Welsh
said of her dad, who in 1923 was one of the last Chinese immigrants let into Canada until
after the Second World War. “This is just such a
once-in-a-lifetime event. He never thought he would see the day.”
   Marr sat in his wheelchair smiling broadly, his eyes
gleaming as the verdant prairie rolled by.
   Gim Wong and his wife Jan were
similarly awed by the grandeur of the landscape and the attention of the
media.
   “I’m overwhelmed, just overwhelmed,”
repeated the 83-yearold Wong, whose late father paid the tax.
   The Toronto-born co-chairwoman of the Ontario Coalition of
Chinese Head Tax Payers and Families, Eng is riding the rails with her mother
Chuey Eng in memory of her late father Tong, who
paid the fee to enter the country in 1919.
   “This railway is part of the mythology of Canada,”
Eng said as the Via train gently rocked its way across the continent.
   “Every child learns that in our schools — now
they will also learn about the Chinese indentured workers who did the hard
jobs.”
   Although the Chinese were courted and welcomed to help
construct the CPR, the federal government shunned them after it was completed
in 1885.
   Those who were landed faced rampant, manifest
discrimination and sporadic violence by the turn of the 20th century.
   They might have played a key role in building the Canadian
Pacific line that ushered B.C. into Confederation, but the Chinese were not
even invited to the celebration marking its finish.
   Of the 82,000 or so estimated to have paid the head tax
— imposed from 1885 until 1923 to staunch immigration — there
remain only a score of aged survivors such as Marr and perhaps 200 of their
spouses.
   There are, though, an estimated 4,000 descendants, several
hundred families whose ancestors paid the fee that was as high as $500.
   Eng and eight others set out Friday from Vancouver,
and were joined by another five, including Marr, in Edmonton. Two found the travel too onerous
and disembarked, hoping to fly to Ottawa.

   None of the abiding ironies of the journey are lost on the
participants.
   They even carry a Last Spike, one of the souvenir steel
pegs distributed at the initial ceremony marking the historic moment when the
eastern and western crews laying down the Canadian Pacific line met.
   The spike was a gift to the redress campaign from the late
author, Pierre Berton, whose books documented the
building of the railway and its importance to the building of the nation.
   Eng plans to bring it to the ceremony Thursday when Harper
will deliver on behalf of Canadians the long-overdue “sorry.”
   Though the tax was abolished in 1923, from then until 1947,
Canada
simply refused entry to Chinese immigrants and denied their families the
right to reunite.
   The hardships that caused for many remain a caustic memory
discussed among those on the trip — which proved a chance for those
involved to strike up new friendships and share emotional bouts of heart-felt
reminiscence about family and friends long gone.
   “My father tried to bring us here after Japan invaded China
in 1937, but the act wouldn’t allow it,” recalled Howe Chan, of Richmond, his eyes
welling as he fingered a faded photograph.
   “My brother died of tuberculosis before the Japanese
surrender and my sister died of meningitis a month before I came here. I
didn’t see my father from the age of one to 14 — to me he was a
total stranger when I arrived here.”
   Like others on the train, he was flabbergasted by
Harper’s decision — a staggering symbolic gesture no one in the
community expected. He scrambled to ensure he was aboard the socalled redress train.
   imulgrew@png.canwest.com

 

image

 

image


   IAN JACKSON/SPECIAL TO THE SUN
Lily
Welsh accompanies her father James Marr, 94 (in the wheelchair),
who holds one of the last spikes from the building of the CPR before he
boards the train to Ottawa from Edmonton Saturday. Marr
is one of the last surviving Chinese-Canadians to have paid the head tax and
is joining a group from Vancouver
honouring thousands of Chinese who gave their lives
to build the rail line.

Calgary Sun: “Apology a start”

Calgary Sun: “Apology
a start”

Here is an article from the Calgary Sun

Chinese
Canadians say head tax issue long overdue

By PABLO FERNANDEZ, CALGARY SUN



Prime
Minister Stephen Harper's apology for the Chinese head tax is a small step in
the start of the healing process for those who suffered from the injustice,
said Calgarian Mary Mah today.

Mah, 85,
was one of dozen Chinese head tax payers, spouses and relatives who boarded a
train in Vancouver,
dubbed the Redress Express, last Friday.

As it
crosses Canada,
the train will collect as many as 100 people who are Ottawa-bound to hear
Harper's official apology on Thursday for the institution of the head tax.

The
apology is important because it means the government will finally acknowledge
the tax was a law based on bigotry and racism, said Mah while waiting to
continue on to Ontario.

“The
government has to admit that law was racist, that what they did was wrong and
immoral,” she said.

“It's
about bringing all this out into the open so that the rest of the people will
know what happened.

“The
apology is the first step but closure is not going to happen overnight.”

The
Chinese head tax, which was implemented in 1885 and revoked in 1923, forced
every Chinese immigrant to pay, at its highest level, a $500 fee to enter the
country.

The tax
likely destroyed thousands of families, said Mah.

“The
tax meant that families were broken apart because fathers were forced to be
alone in Canada and their
wives and children were left in China,”
she said.

“It
was a very difficult solitary life … they were never allowed to bond with
their families and that was a very big injustice.

“The
apology is symbolic … for the tragedy that it was.”

Approximately
81,000 people had to pay the tax and of those, only 20 are still alive today,
said Ontario Coalition of Chinese Head Tax Payers, Spouses and Descendants
spokeswoman Avvy Go.

“This
comes 20 years too late,” said Go of the apology.

“Even
if the government didn't offer a formal apology, they should've done something
by now.”

Mah was 3
years old when she arrived in Victoria on May
16, 1923, making her one of the youngest persons ever to pay the tax and one of
the last Chinese immigrants to pay to enter Canada.

It cost
her father $1,000 to get her and her mother into the country, said Mah, whose
father was second generation Canadian but who was forced to pay to reunite with
his wife, whom he met when he returned to China as a young man.

 

BC Coalition of Head Tax Payers: “One certificate, one payment is fair”


BC Coalition of Head Tax Payers:
"One certificate, one payment is fair"

BC Coalition of Head Tax Payers, Spouses and Descendants


For immediate release - Tuesday June 20, 2006

Vancouver, BC - The BC Coalition of Head Tax Payers, Spouses and
Descendants believes the position of "one certificate, one payment" is
principled, fair and inclusive. We are concerned with the federal
government's unilateral imposition of the upcoming Chinese Head
Tax/Exclusion redress settlement.

"Our request for a meeting to work with the government to discuss the
redress package prior to the June 22 announcement has been turned
down." states Karin Lee, BC Coalition spokesperson and grand-daughter
of head tax payers. "We are disappointed that the government has not
been open and transparent with redress groups across the country as
well as with head tax families, and are unnecessarily rushing through
the process. "

"When redress started over 20 years ago many head tax payers and
spouses were still alive," states Harvey Lee, a BC Coalition
spokesperson, senior and son of a head tax payer. "The government
should not be rewarded for their intransigence and failure to act for
the last two decades."

The BC Coalition would like to inform head tax families, the Chinese
community and all Canadians, that on June 22nd, 2006, the federal
government will simulcast Prime Minister Harper's apology for the Head
Tax and Exclusion Act legislation from the House of Commons. This
public event will take place at the Fairmont Hotel Vancouver from noon
to 3pm.

The BC Coalition is arranging transportation for the elderly and those
who need assistance. Transportation will be provided from 10 am - 11
am, from SUCCESS - 28 West Pender Street, and will return from Hotel
Vancouver to SUCCESS from 3 - 4pm.

Members of the BC Coalition will attend and witness this historical
and, hopefully celebratory occasion in the BC ballroom of the Fairmont
Hotel Vancouver at Burrard and Georgia.

The BC Coalition is a volunteer multi-partisan organization, and works
toward a just redress for the families affected by the head tax and
the Exclusion Act. We are individuals and families who are head tax
payers, spouses and descendants of our early Chinese Canadian
pioneers. We at the Coalition also comprise more recent Chinese
immigrants from Hong Kong, China and elsewhere who believe that it is
important for all of us to work together for justice for the victims
of government discrimination. After all, we are all Canadian and all
Chinese.

-30-


For more information, please contact:

BC Coalition of Head Tax Payers, Spouses and Descendants

Grace Schenkeveld English-language spokesperson (604) 506-1703

Harvey Lee English-language spokesperson (778) 883-2606

Karin Lee, English-language spokesperson (778) 773-1088

Gabriel Yiu, Chinese-language spokesperson (604) 889-0696

Vancouver Sun: Redress train rolls by ghosts of the past

Here's an article on the Redress Train, with interviews by Sun reporter Ian Mulgrew….

Monday Â» June 19 Â» 2006
 

Redress train rolls by ghosts of the past
 
Ian Mulgrew
Vancouver Sun


Aboard the Head Tax Redress Train
As
the transcontinental train clattered eastward through the Rockies,
Toronto's Susan Eng entertained tourists with stories of the 22-year
struggle by Chinese Canadians for redress over the long-gone
discriminatory head tax.

More time, Eng told them, would have
allowed the groups involved to better organize the response to Prime
Minister Stephen Harper's surprise announcement last week that he would
apologize for the unique penalty imposed on the Chinese more than a
century ago.
“It would have been nice along the way on this
trip to commemorate the thousands of Chinese workers who gave their
lives to build the railway,” Eng said.

But the train rumbled
through Kamloops at midnight and most of the sites appropriate for a
ritualistic nod to the ghosts of the past were also shrouded in
darkness as the train sped by.

Later, the
observation car filled with “ahs” at the appearance of Thunder Falls on
the opposite side of mirror-like Moose Lake near the B.C.-Alberta
border.
“Wow,” Eng echoed, watching the spectacular spires
and rugged ranges through which her ancestors helped carve and blast a
steel path.

She said she hopes this thrown-together trip will
nevertheless focus Canadians' attention and help them understand why
the prime minister's decision means so much to the minority community.

James
Marr, 94, and his family had only two days notice before they boarded
the Canadian in Edmonton late Saturday for the trip to Ottawa.

“He's
quite overwhelmed,” daughter Lily Welsh said of her dad, who in 1923
was one of the last Chinese immigrants let into Canada until after the
Second World War. “This is just such a once-in-a-lifetime event. He
never thought he would see the day.”
Marr sat in
his wheelchair smiling broadly, his eyes gleaming as the verdant prairie rolled by.

Gim Wong and his wife Jan were similarly awed by the grandeur of the landscape and the attention of the media.

“I'm overwhelmed, just overwhelmed,” repeated the 83-year-old Wong, whose late father paid the tax.

The
Toronto-born co-chairwoman of the Ontario Coalition of Chinese Head Tax
Payers and Families, Eng is riding the rails with her mother Chuey Eng
in memory of her late father Tong, who paid the fee to enter the
country in 1919.

“This railway is part of the mythology of Canada,” Eng said as the Via train gently rocked its way across the continent.

“Every child learns that in our schools — now they will also learn about the Chinese indentured workers who did the hard jobs.”

Although
the Chinese were courted and welcomed to help construct the CPR, the
federal government shunned them after it was completed in 1885.

Those who were landed faced rampant, manifest discrimination and sporadic violence by the turn of the 20th century.

They
might have played a key role in building the Canadian Pacific line that
ushered B.C. into Confederation, but the Chinese were not even invited
to the celebration marking its finish.

Of the 82,000 or so
estimated to have paid the head tax — imposed from 1885 until 1923 to
staunch immigration — there remain only a score of aged survivors such
as Marr and perhaps 200 of their spouses.

There are, though,
an estimated 4,000 descendants, several hundred families whose
ancestors paid the fee that was as high as $500.

Eng and
eight others set out Friday from Vancouver, and were joined by another
five, including Marr, in Edmonton. Two found the travel too onerous and
disembarked, hoping to fly to Ottawa.

None of the abiding ironies of the journey are lost on the participants.
They
even carry a Last Spike, one of the souvenir steel pegs distributed at
the initial ceremony marking the historic moment when the eastern and
western crews laying down the Canadian Pacific line met.

The
spike was a gift to the redress campaign from the late author, Pierre
Berton, whose books documented the building of the railway and its
importance to the building of the nation.

Eng plans to bring it to the ceremony Thursday when Harper will deliver on behalf of Canadians the long-overdue “sorry.”

Though
the tax was abolished in 1923, from then until 1947, Canada simply
refused entry to Chinese immigrants and denied their families the right
to reunite.

The hardships that caused for many remain a
caustic memory discussed among those on the trip — which proved a
chance for those involved to strike up new friendships and share
emotional bouts of heart-felt reminiscence about family and friends
long gone.

“My father tried to bring us here after Japan
invaded China in 1937, but the act wouldn't allow it,” recalled Howe
Chan, of Richmond, his eyes welling as he fingered a faded photograph.

“My
brother died of tuberculosis before the Japanese surrender and my
sister died of meningitis a month before I came here. I didn't see my
father from the age of one to 14 — to me he was a total stranger when
I arrived here.”

Like others on the train, he was
flabbergasted by Harper's decision — a staggering symbolic gesture no
one in the community expected. He scrambled to ensure he was aboard the
so-called redress train.

imulgrew@png.canwest.com

© The Vancouver Sun 2006